Miami-Dade therapist sentenced to 4-years for Medicare fraud

Following her conviction on one count of conspiracy to submit false and fraudulent claims to Medicare through her employer — American Therapeutic Corporation (ATC) and a related company, American Sleep Institute — Nichole Eckert a mental health therapist has been sentenced to  four years in prison, followed by three years of supervised release. She also was ordered  to pay more than $72 million in restitution, jointly and severally, with her co-defendants for participating in a $205 million Medicare fraud scheme.

A doctor is being arrested for Medicare fraud.ATC, headquartered in Miami, operated partial hospitalization programs (PHPs) in locations in South Florida and Orlando. According to the U.S. Attorney’s press release, ATC secured patients by paying kickbacks to assisted living facility owners and halfway house owners who would then steer patients to ATC for PHP treatments.

The referred patients were found to be ineligible for the PHP treatments which  ATC billed to Medicare. Funds received from Medicare were laundered by some of the co-conspirators to create cash to pay kickbacks.

Eckert’s role was to fabricate patient files to substantiate Medicare claims and make it appear that ATC patients were qualified for PHP treatment. The false records also showed that patients were receiving the intensive, individualized treatment PHPs are supposed to provide.  Some or the patients were ineligible for PHP treatments. ATC, a related company, Medlink, and dozens of individuals have previously been convicted at trial or pleaded guilty for their participation in the scheme.

Case Study: Independent ASC’s and outside physicians

May 21, 2012 — Question: An independent ambulatory surgery center (ASC) is open just a few days a week. It is staffed by physicians from the provider group that owns the center.

In an effort to increase revenue, the ASC is considering a deal with an outside, small provider group that seeks to use the ASC on the days when it is usually closed. As part of the agreement, the outside group would be credentialed by the ASC, allowing it to use the ASC’s operating rooms and support staff, without charge.

The outside group would bill its own professional fees, while the ASC would bill for use of the facility. In today’s regulatory environment, should the owners of the ASC be concerned that allowing the outside group to use the ASC for free would constitute a kickback?

Can an ASC allow a provider to come in, use the operating rooms and bill their own fees, without any type of agreement?

Answer: While it may be best to draw up a written agreement setting forth the terms and conditions for using the center’s operating rooms — including for example credentialing the physicians who will use the facility — as long as the outside providers aren’t receiving a cut of the facility fees, then the federal Anti-Kickback Statute (AKS) should not apply. Because outside physician groups are only performing surgery at the ASC, and billing for their professional services, then the arrangement should be no different than if the doctors were performing surgery at a hospital with each party billing for the services they provide.

But, what if the independent physician group wanted to rent the ASC for blocks of time during which they could perform their surgical procedures?  That is also possible provided that the parties enter into a rental agreement meeting both safe harbor and Stark regulatory requirements. The physician group may then be entitled to both a facility fee and their professional fee, subject to applicable state licensure laws and the requirements of Medicare and third-party payers.

Lee Lasris, partner, Florida Health Law Center



Specializing in all areas of health law including fraud and abuse, bioethics, health care business transactions, HIPAA, compliance programs, pharmaceutical, managed care, clinical trials, medical staff issues, contracting and licensure issues.


(888) 491-1120